Rahv in an article on dostoevsky in crime and punishment makes a. Dubber, rediscovering hegels theory of crime and punishment, 92 mich. This project examines the role of the left hegelian school of philosophy in crime and punishment by fyodor dostoevsky. Hegel on crime and punishment american political science. Rediscovering hegel s theory of crime and punishment markus dirk dubber suny buffalo follow this and additional works at. This systematic approach is thought a superior alternative to all other ways of philosophical thinking. During the time of the novel in 1866, the extraordinary was a popular theory. Brooks argues that the consensus view of hegels theory of punishment as straightforwardly retributivist is mistaken. Hegels philosophy of history general introduction to the philosophy of history source.
Stillman that hegel expounded a justification of punishment is clear. Summary of hegels philosophy of mind paul trejo, august 1993 for over 180 years students have complained that hegels bestknown book of philosophy, the phenomenology of mind alias phenomenology of spirit, is too difficult to read. This chapter examines the philosophies of hegel and marx. Examining hegels jena manuscripts, his philosophy of right, the phenomenology of spirit, and other works, williams shows how the concept of recognition shapes and illumines hegels understandings of crime and punishment, morality, the family, the state, sovereignty, international relations, and war. Hegel is clear that punishment is only justified where it is deserved by an offender for committing a crime. Women may have happy inspirations, taste, elegance, but they have not the ideal. For example, while merle focuses his interpretation of hegel s justification of punishment on the discussion of abstract right in the philosophy of right, it is far from clear that hegel took himself to have completely addressed the problem in that text alone. Award winners book club selections books by author books by series coming soon kids books new releases teens books this. Hegels complete views on crime and punishment journal.
Hegels philosophy of right georg wilhelm friedrich hegel. Hegel on punishment 171 denial or negation of the freedom and fights of the victim s will. In hegels own phrase, it is an immanent and an incessant dialectic, which from first to last allows finality to no dogmatic rest, but carries out kants. Special attention is given to georg hegels section on world historical individuals from philosophy of history and rodion raskolnikovs philosophy from crime and punishment. Originally published in 1971, this volume was created to commemorate the bicentenary of hegel s birth in 1770. In this article, i argue that hegels complete and mature view of crime and punishment is more robust than many interpretations of the unrecht passage in the abstract right section of hegels elements of the philosophy of right suggest. He deals with this subject in the ninetyninth and subsequent paragraphs of his book on the philosophy of law, and there he expressly says. The project gutenberg ebook of hegels philosophy of mind.
The trouble with hegels political philosophy, however, is. Hegels views on crime and punishment in 199117 marked the first time since 1936 that a german text had discussed hegels punishment theory in substantial detail. Having read much about dostoevskys life and influences,i think i. The text argues that raskolnikov is largely an agent of left hegelianism created by dostoevsky to illustrate a philosophy that the author opposed. Part of the law and philosophy commons recommended citation markus d. Philosophy of law, and there he expressly says that it is. Full text of hegels conception of crime and punishment see other formats stop early journal content on jstor, free to anyone in the world this article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by jstor. Due perhaps to his frequently obscure writing style and idiosyncratic terminology, hegels account of punishment has generally not received widespread attention or a favorable reception in englishspeaking jurisprudence. Thirteen essays are included from experts with diverse approaches, concentrating on the central issues of hegel s political philosophy, and covering all of the major political works. Rediscovering hegel s theory of crime and punishment, markus dirk dubber. But generally extracted from various parts of his philosophy, his views may be stated with some consistency. Scholarly and thoughtprovoking, hegels philosophy of right offers important new insights into our understanding of hegels seminal philosophy of right and the broader world of hegelian philosophy. Hegels philosophy of right georg wilhelm friedrich.
The will can be coerced simply because it exists in property in order to manifest its freedom. Unique focus on hegels method and system applied to political philosophy. Hegel offers us comments about punishment that support this interpretation. More specifically, it is to the dialectical unfolding of the notion of right that we must turn our immediate attention. Hegels complete views on crime and punishment volume 4 issue 4 andrew komasinski. Rediscovering hegels theory of crime and punishment. This is a critical analysis of the book, not hegels work. Hegel s method of arriving at such answers is by no means alien to those employed by contemporary analytic philosophers. Page 9 phavorinus, legum opportunitates et medelas pro temporum moribus et pro rerum publicarum generibus, ac pro utilitatum praesentium rationibus, proque vitiorum, quibus medendum est, fervoribus, mutari ac flecti, neque uno statu consistere, quin, ut facies coeli et maris, ita rerum atque fortunae tempestatibus varientur. While exerting a profound influence on several major philosophical movements, the groundbreaki. In contract the principle of rightness is present as something posited, while its inner universality is there as something common in the arbitrariness and particular will of the parties. An overview for hegel, punishment is the dialectical overcoming of crime. Hegels philosophy of right audiobook by thom brooks. And, at first sight, it looks very much as if he did.
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content hegels idea of punishment peter g. A guide to the abbreviations i use in citing hegels works appears at the front of this book. Michael salter and his authors have succeeded in showing that hegel, through his contemporary interpreters, continues to play a relevant and controversial role in a wide range of scholarly debates, from the critique of liberalism and rights, to gender issues. The legitimacy of capital punishment in hegels philosophy of right. Georg wilhelm friedrich hegels philosophy of right is widely acknowledged as one of the most important texts in the history of moral and political philosophy. Sep 19, 2018 thom brookss essay on crime and punishment is distinctive in the volume for its more narrow focus on a concrete topic within hegels practical philosophy. Hegels view on punishment is often the object of scorn or ridicule. Since one of my main concerns with contemporary criminal law theory is that it does not sufficiently address the larger setting of criminal law, id insist that we add works on the history and sociology of crime and punishment and on political philosophy more broadly. This philosophy is not a return to the letter of hegel, but certainly a return to the spirit of his great conception that in the absolute idea everything finds its in terpretation. Page 174 women can, of course, be educated, but their minds are not adapted to the higher sciences, philosophy, or certain of the arts.
Georg wilhelm friedrich hegel s philosophy of right is widely acknowledged as one of the most important texts in the history of moral and political philosophy. Rediscovering hegels theory of crime and punishment markus dirk dubber suny buffalo follow this and additional works at. Jun, 2018 hegel offers us comments about punishment that support this interpretation. Hegels method of arriving at such answers is by no means alien to those employed by contemporary analytic philosophers. This chapter offers a systematic reading of hegels comments about punishment in his philosophical system with careful attention to his philosophy of right.
This is a fine collection of highly engaging and accessible scholarly essays on hegels philosophy of right. Steinberger focuses on four issues that are particularly revealing of hegels political philosophy in generalcrime and punishment, morality, marriage, and the structure of the rational stateand shows that hegels reconciliation of individual and social interests within the state is both illuminating and internally consistent. The type, logic, and details of his justification, however, are less clear. Thom brookss essay on crime and punishment is distinctive in the volume for its more narrow focus on a concrete topic within hegels practical philosophy. Mark tunick to scholars of western intellectual history hegel is one of the most important of all political thinkers, but politicians and other downtoearth persons see his speculative philosophy as far. Hegels last major published work, is an attempt to systematize ethical theory, natural right, the philosophy of law, political theory and the sociology of the modern state into the framework of hegels philosophy of history. In the novel crime and punishment raskolnikov and other characters believe they are extraordinary and will not be punished for the crimes they commit. Punishment aspires to be a cancellation of a crime and its illeffects in a restoration of right restoring rights violated by a crime pr, 99. We will give a close reading to hegels philosophy of right, with some additional readings from hegels phenomenology and other of his works, and some readings by kant, burke, and aristotle. Dostoevskys hegelian parody in crime and punishment.
Crime and punishment is a novel by fyodor dostoevsky, one of the founders of the modern novel. The rediscovery of hegel s philosophy, among those trained in the angloamerican tradition, continues to spur contemporary thinkers toward new appropriations of hegel s thought. The philosophy, into which this view of crime and punishment most naturally fits, is already not only in the air, but to some ex tent at least on solid ground. Hegels idea of crime as a negation, which must be annulled, derives. He is editor and founder of the journal of moral philosophy. The text argues that raskolnikov is largely an agent of left hegelianism created by. Hegels views on crime and punishment in 199117 marked the first. Pdf hegel on crime and punishment thom brooks academia. English books on the philosophy of right4 discuss hegels political and moral philosophy. Confession and forgiveness in hegel and dostoevsky squarespace. Reviews this collection should be essential reading for everyone interested in legal and constitutional theory. Hegels complete views on crime and punishment journal of the.
The trouble with hegels political philosophy, however, is that it aims both too high and too low. Hegel on punishment 171 denial or negation of the freedom and fights of the victims will. While exerting a profound influence on several major philosophical movements, the groundbreaking 1820 work continues to shape philosophical thought. One problem is the inadequacy of punishment as described in abstract right. The most widespread interpretation amongst contemporary theorists of kants theory of punishment is that it is retributivist. The philosophy of right constitutes, along with hegels philosophy of history, the penultimate section of his encyclopedia, the section on objective spirit, which deals with the human world and its array of social rules and institutions, including the moral, legal, religious, economic, and political as well as marriage, the family, social. Hegels complete views on crime and punishment request pdf. Hegel on crime and punishment in brooks and sebastian stein eds. Hegels criticism of morality, or moralitat, has had a decisive influence in the reception of his thought.
Hegels philosophy of right audiobook thom brooks audible. First, i explain the value of revisiting the interpretation of hegel as a simple retributionist in the contemporary debate. Examining hegel s jena manuscripts, his philosophy of right, the phenomenology of spirit, and other works, williams shows how the concept of recognition shapes and illumines hegel s understandings of crime and punishment, morality, the family, the state, sovereignty, international relations, and war. The emphasis will be on bringing hegel s political theory to bear on our own politics and practices. Hegel on crime and punishment volume 77 issue 4 peter j. On the contrary, i will argue there are very different senses in which kant discusses punishment. The emphasis will be on bringing hegels political theory to bear on our own politics and practices. Steinberger treats hegels political philosophy explicitly in items of the general methodological principles hegel sets forth in the logic, offering the first systematic effort to bridge the gap between these two areas of hegelian thought. The difference between man and woman is the same as that between animal and plant.
Georg wilhelm friedrich hegel, reason in history, a general introduction to the philosophy of history, a liberal arts press book, the bobbsmerrill company, inc. This book is a translation of a classic work of modern social and political thought, elements of the philosophy of right. He endorses retribution for moral law transgressions and consequentialist considerations for positive law violations. Then, i look at hegels treatment of crime and punishment in the section on abstract.
By general acknowledgment, while his writings support a broadly neoaristotelian ethics of selfactualization, his views on moral philosophy are exhausted by his criticisms of kant, whom he treats as paradigmatic exponent of the standpoint of morality. The concepts of crime and punishment play a central role in hegel s philosophy of right. Thom brooks is reader in political and legal philosophy at newcastle university. Crime and punishment tells the story of redemption. On the normative significance of method and system. Hegel famously argues that his speculative method is a foundation for claims about sociopolitical reality within a wider philosophical system.
Full text of hegels conception of crime and punishment. We will give a close reading to hegel s philosophy of right, with some additional readings from hegel s phenomenology and other of his works, and some readings by kant, burke, and aristotle. It argues that the conventional reading, which claims his theory of punishment is mostly confined to the section abstract right, raises interpretive difficulties. Dubber, rediscovering hegel s theory of crime and punishment, 92 mich. In its broadest statement, the hegelian man exists for noble purposes.
Full text of hegel s conception of crime and punishment see other formats stop early journal content on jstor, free to anyone in the world this article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by jstor. Brings together leading hegel scholars from across the world to consider this topic in one book for the first time. The essays focus on ethics, politics, and law and highlight with great originality the significance of hegels thought for contemporary debates concerning value theory, kantian formalism, punishment theory, political organisation, gender equality, standards of justice, and legal. As the first moment in which the notion of right truly encounters an other, crime is thus the. On the normative significance of method and system edited by thom brooks and. This is a draft of a chapter that was accepted for publication by oxford university press in the book hegels political philosophy. Public users can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter. For example, while merle focuses his interpretation of hegels justification of punishment on the discussion of abstract right in the philosophy of right, it is far from clear that hegel took himself to have completely addressed the problem in that text alone.
Mark tunicks new book is an excellent example of such an appropriation in the context of modern political and legal philosophy. The truth is that i found the plot too simple for a writer of dostoevskys standard and was sure that there was something more complex lying behind raskolnikovs mental and ultimately physical punishment as a result of committing a crime. This novel deals with the question of responsibility for the actions of each individual, background of struggle between god, morality and the theory of the superman. Originally published in 1971, this volume was created to commemorate the bicentenary of hegels birth in 1770. In contract the principle of rightness is present as something posited, while its inner universality is there as something common in the arbitrariness and particular will of. This is in stark contrast to the space devoted to, and more ready acceptance of, hegels. Hegel writes that punishment makes null the crime,11 a claim one re cent commentator dismisses as obscure,12 and to which another re sponds. It is a system which is selfcritical, and systematic only through the absoluteness of its criticism. I read crime and punishment in 20 and liked it,although not so much as most people. The discussion of marxs views includes his thoughts about hegels philosophy, capitalism, and bourgeois moral theory. Elements of the philosophy of right by georg wilhelm. The analysis of hegel draws upon his book, philosophy of right 1820. Thirteen essays are included from experts with diverse approaches, concentrating on the central issues of hegels political philosophy, and covering all of the major political works.
Kants theory of punishment utilitas cambridge core. The ubermensch or extraordinary man theories cliffsnotes. The concepts of crime and punishment play a central role in hegels philosophy of right. Hegels political philosophy on the normative significance of method and system edited by thom brooks and sebastian stein. Social and political thought internet encyclopedia. Thus, as one would expect, the theory of crime and punishment can only be understood in terms of the hegelian dialectic. Within the dialectic of abstract right, crime announces a problem that ultimately.
313 323 1397 1501 247 1068 1566 321 715 157 1558 53 1279 869 458 1420 1380 681 563 912 1057 458 90 588 904 1336 1039 1467 1191 108 651 53